Help us shape the future of the DOI website. Share your thoughts in our survey.
Official Government Website

Consumer Complaint Comparison Tables

The consumer complaint comparison tables provide you with helpful information to assess your insurance company and compare it against other insurance companies.

Definitions:

YearCategoryCompany NamePremiumMarket Share# of ComplaintsIndex
2020AutoState Farm Mut Auto Ins Co $143,385,405 12.0%00
2020AutoFarm Bureau Mut Ins Co Of ID $121,112,389 11.0%11.9
2020AutoSafeco Ins Co Of IL $102,996,271 9.0%12.23
2020AutoAllstate Fire & Cas Ins Co $74,828,972 7.0%00
2020AutoFarmers Ins Co Of ID $75,338,575 7.0%00
2020AutoProgressive Northwestern Ins Co $70,734,494 6.0%00
2020AutoGEICO Advantage Ins Co $54,413,969 5.0%00
2020AutoProgressive Direct Ins Co $59,465,946 5.0%13.86
2020AutoGEICO Choice Ins Co $33,055,469 3.0%00
2020AutoAuto Owners Ins Co $19,469,370 2.0%00
2020AutoLM Gen Ins Co $24,703,547 2.0%00
2020AutoStandard Fire Ins Co $22,369,192 2.0%00
2020AutoUnited Serv Automobile Assn $22,312,429 2.0%00
2020AutoUSAA Cas Ins Co $22,437,649 2.0%00
2020AutoUSAA Gen Ind Co $18,071,384 2.0%00
2020AutoViking Ins Co Of WI $22,321,353 2.0%110.29
2020AutoAmerican Family Ins Co $16,443,270 1.0%00
2020AutoGeico Gen Ins Co $13,092,618 1.0%00
2020AutoGEICO Secure Ins Co $12,014,296 1.0%00
2020AutoState Farm Fire & Cas Co $14,078,495 1.0%00
2020Group Accident/HealthBlue Cross of ID Hlth Serv Inc $833,343,617 45.0%11.11
2020Group Accident/HealthRegence Blueshield Of ID Inc $265,378,441 14.0%00
2020Group Accident/HealthSelectHealth Inc $134,626,218 7.0%00
2020Group Accident/HealthUnitedHealthcare Ins Co $89,408,016 5.0%00
2020Group Accident/HealthDelta Dental Plan of ID Inc $67,241,682 4.0%00
2020Group Accident/HealthPacificsource Hlth Plans $81,655,409 4.0%00
2020Group Accident/HealthAetna Life Ins Co $29,179,968 2.0%00
2020Group Accident/HealthCigna Hlth & Life Ins Co $45,331,466 2.0%00
2020Group Accident/HealthHumana Ins Co $20,227,375 1.0%00
2020Group Accident/HealthLife Ins Co Of N Amer $12,773,890 1.0%00
2020Group Accident/HealthMetropolitan Life Ins Co $17,077,414 1.0%00
2020Group Accident/HealthSilverScript Ins Co $11,552,117 1.0%00
2020Group Accident/HealthStandard Ins Co $9,327,978 1.0%00
2020Group Accident/HealthWellCare Prescription Ins Inc $16,503,691 1.0%00
2020Group Accident/HealthWillamette Dental of ID Inc $14,800,181 1.0%00
2020Group Accident/HealthBlue Cross of ID Care Plus Inc $8,521,242 0.0%00
2020Group Accident/HealthHCC Life Ins Co $8,819,584 0.0%00
2020Group Accident/HealthPrincipal Life Ins Co $8,916,096 0.0%00
2020Group Accident/HealthTimber Products Manufacturers Trust $8,831,292 0.0%00
2020Group Accident/HealthUnum Life Ins Co Of Amer $8,606,331 0.0%00
2020HomeownerState Farm Fire & Cas Co $67,010,164 15.0%00
2020HomeownerFarm Bureau Mut Ins Co Of ID $43,011,488 9.0%00
2020HomeownerSafeco Ins Co Of IL $38,570,258 8.0%15.93
2020HomeownerFarmers Ins Exch $26,195,638 6.0%00
2020HomeownerAllstate Vehicle & Prop Ins Co $21,169,008 5.0%00
2020HomeownerUnited Serv Automobile Assn $16,379,491 4.0%00
2020HomeownerAmerican Economy Ins Co $15,548,800 3.0%00
2020HomeownerAuto Owners Ins Co $12,181,597 3.0%00
2020HomeownerLiberty Ins Corp $13,249,625 3.0%00
2020HomeownerUnited Heritage Prop & Cas Co $12,156,719 3.0%00
2020HomeownerFarmers Ins Co Of ID $10,756,259 2.0%00
2020HomeownerForemost Ins Co Grand Rapids MI $9,130,082 2.0%00
2020HomeownerTravco Ins Co $10,992,941 2.0%00
2020HomeownerTravelers Home & Marine Ins Co $9,109,538 2.0%00
2020HomeownerUSAA Cas Ins Co $10,959,517 2.0%00
2020HomeownerUSAA Gen Ind Co $7,712,620 2.0%00
2020HomeownerAIG Prop Cas Co $5,512,217 1.0%00
2020HomeownerAmerican Family Mut Ins Co SI $6,610,542 1.0%00
2020HomeownerMutual Of Enumclaw Ins Co $5,538,639 1.0%00
2020HomeownerVigilant Ins Co $6,296,689 1.0%00
2020Individual Accident/HealthBlue Cross of ID Hlth Serv Inc $425,046,062 32.0%20.52
2020Individual Accident/HealthSelectHealth Inc $327,248,433 25.0%00
2020Individual Accident/HealthDelta Dental Plan of ID Inc $67,241,682 5.0%00
2020Individual Accident/HealthMontana Hlth Cooperative $69,034,790 5.0%57.94
2020Individual Accident/HealthRegence Blueshield Of ID Inc $57,150,653 4.0%00
2020Individual Accident/HealthAetna Hlth & Life Ins Co $20,104,140 2.0%00
2020Individual Accident/HealthAmerican Family Life Assur Co of Col $31,973,060 2.0%00
2020Individual Accident/HealthContinental Life Ins Co Brentwood $22,650,811 2.0%00
2020Individual Accident/HealthHumana Ins Co $20,227,375 2.0%00
2020Individual Accident/HealthBlue Cross of ID Care Plus Inc $8,521,242 1.0%00
2020Individual Accident/HealthGenworth Life Ins Co $8,027,646 1.0%00
2020Individual Accident/HealthMutual Of Omaha Ins Co $18,166,602 1.0%00
2020Individual Accident/HealthNorthwestern Mut Life Ins Co $8,282,487 1.0%00
2020Individual Accident/HealthOmaha Ins Co $7,150,398 1.0%00
2020Individual Accident/HealthPacificsource Hlth Plans $17,139,837 1.0%00
2020Individual Accident/HealthSilverScript Ins Co $11,552,117 1.0%00
2020Individual Accident/HealthTransamerica Life Ins Co $12,195,093 1.0%00
2020Individual Accident/HealthUnited Of Omaha Life Ins Co $10,212,540 1.0%00
2020Individual Accident/HealthWellCare Prescription Ins Inc $16,503,691 1.0%00
2020Individual Accident/HealthWillamette Dental of ID Inc $14,800,181 1.0%00
2019AutoState Farm Mut Auto Ins Co $137,190,877 12.4%00
2019AutoFarm Bureau Mut Ins Co Of ID $116,424,524 10.5%23.17
2019AutoSafeco Ins Co Of IL $90,942,360 8.2%00
2019AutoFarmers Ins Co Of ID $76,630,039 6.9%00
2019AutoAllstate Fire & Cas Ins Co $70,146,014 6.3%00
2019AutoProgressive Northwestern Ins Co $65,281,866 5.9%00
2019AutoProgressive Direct Ins Co $52,756,251 4.8%00
2019AutoGEICO Advantage Ins Co $49,792,232 4.5%27.42
2019AutoGEICO Choice Ins Co $31,018,057 2.8%00
2019AutoLM Gen Ins Co $22,519,013 2.0%00
2019AutoUnited Serv Automobile Assn $21,137,358 1.9%00
2019AutoAuto Owners Ins Co $20,445,022 1.9%00
2019AutoUSAA Cas Ins Co $20,422,083 1.8%00
2019AutoStandard Fire Ins Co $20,012,242 1.8%00
2019AutoViking Ins Co Of WI $19,523,689 1.8%00
2019AutoAmerican Family Ins Co $17,350,596 1.6%00
2019AutoUSAA Gen Ind Co $16,836,928 1.5%00
2019AutoGeico Gen Ins Co $15,885,943 1.4%00
2019AutoState Farm Fire & Cas Co $14,917,235 1.4%00
2019AutoGEICO Secure Ins Co $11,480,121 1.0%00
2019Group Accident/HealthBlue Cross of ID Hlth Serv Inc $833,481,528 45.9%51.56
2019Group Accident/HealthRegence Blueshield Of ID Inc $280,486,106 15.5%10.92
2019Group Accident/HealthSelectHealth Inc $107,483,157 5.9%12.41
2019Group Accident/HealthUnitedHealthcare Ins Co $92,716,335 5.1%00
2019Group Accident/HealthPacificsource Hlth Plans $75,061,067 4.1%00
2019Group Accident/HealthDelta Dental Plan of ID Inc $64,052,510 3.5%00
2019Group Accident/HealthCigna Hlth & Life Ins Co $44,133,604 2.4%00
2019Group Accident/HealthAetna Life Ins Co $29,810,313 1.6%00
2019Group Accident/HealthHumana Ins Co $23,781,643 1.3%00
2019Group Accident/HealthMetropolitan Life Ins Co $16,957,844 0.9%00
2019Group Accident/HealthWellCare Prescription Ins Inc $16,324,941 0.9%00
2019Group Accident/HealthSilverScript Ins Co $14,583,553 0.8%00
2019Group Accident/HealthWillamette Dental of ID Inc $13,617,834 0.8%00
2019Group Accident/HealthLife Ins Co Of N Amer $12,636,643 0.7%00
2019Group Accident/HealthUnum Life Ins Co Of Amer $8,983,919 0.5%00
2019Group Accident/HealthPrincipal Life Ins Co $8,804,926 0.5%00
2019Group Accident/HealthStandard Ins Co $8,427,103 0.5%00
2019Group Accident/HealthHartford Life & Accident Ins Co $7,119,000 0.4%00
2019Group Accident/HealthMedco Containment Life Ins Co $6,670,879 0.4%00
2019Group Accident/HealthTimber Products Manufacturers Trust $6,661,911 0.4%00
2019HomeownerState Farm Fire & Cas Co $63,003,354 14.8%00
2019HomeownerSafeco Ins Co Of IL $43,066,928 10.1%00
2019HomeownerFarm Bureau Mut Ins Co Of ID $41,141,423 9.7%13.44
2019HomeownerFarmers Ins Exch $24,172,495 5.7%00
2019HomeownerAllstate Vehicle & Prop Ins Co $18,323,132 4.3%00
2019HomeownerUnited Serv Automobile Assn $15,052,764 3.5%00
2019HomeownerUnited Heritage Prop & Cas Co $12,593,302 3.0%00
2019HomeownerLiberty Ins Corp $12,220,558 2.9%00
2019HomeownerAuto Owners Ins Co $11,689,241 2.8%00
2019HomeownerFarmers Ins Co Of ID $11,371,940 2.7%00
2019HomeownerTravelers Home & Marine Ins Co $10,252,731 2.4%00
2019HomeownerUSAA Cas Ins Co $9,545,691 2.3%00
2019HomeownerForemost Ins Co Grand Rapids MI $8,398,230 2.0%00
2019HomeownerAmerican Family Mut Ins Co SI $7,015,690 1.7%120.19
2019HomeownerUSAA Gen Ind Co $6,616,156 1.6%00
2019HomeownerMutual Of Enumclaw Ins Co $6,130,129 1.4%00
2019HomeownerTravco Ins Co $5,994,090 1.4%00
2019HomeownerAllstate Prop & Cas Ins Co $5,514,699 1.3%00
2019HomeownerMetropolitan Prop & Cas Ins Co $5,457,000 1.3%125.96
2019HomeownerAllstate Ind Co $5,229,681 1.2%00
2019Individual Accident/HealthBlue Cross of ID Hlth Serv Inc $350,865,937 29.5%10.18
2019Individual Accident/HealthSelectHealth Inc $262,952,354 22.1%00
2019Individual Accident/HealthMontana Hlth Cooperative $92,384,297 7.8%85.41
2019Individual Accident/HealthRegence Blueshield Of ID Inc $65,403,558 5.5%10.96
2019Individual Accident/HealthDelta Dental Plan of ID Inc $64,052,510 5.4%00
2019Individual Accident/HealthAmerican Family Life Assur Co of Col $32,491,858 2.7%00
2019Individual Accident/HealthContinental Life Ins Co Brentwood $23,944,142 2.0%00
2019Individual Accident/HealthHumana Ins Co $23,781,643 2.0%12.63
2019Individual Accident/HealthMutual Of Omaha Ins Co $18,697,875 1.6%00
2019Individual Accident/HealthWellCare Prescription Ins Inc $16,324,941 1.4%00
2019Individual Accident/HealthAetna Hlth & Life Ins Co $15,783,053 1.3%00
2019Individual Accident/HealthSilverScript Ins Co $14,583,553 1.2%00
2019Individual Accident/HealthWillamette Dental of ID Inc $13,617,834 1.2%00
2019Individual Accident/HealthUnited Of Omaha Life Ins Co $10,878,737 0.9%00
2019Individual Accident/HealthPacificsource Hlth Plans $10,677,281 0.9%00
2019Individual Accident/HealthTransamerica Premier Life Ins Co $9,580,883 0.8%00
2019Individual Accident/HealthNorthwestern Mut Life Ins Co $8,027,142 0.7%00
2019Individual Accident/HealthGenworth Life Ins Co $7,787,996 0.7%00
2019Individual Accident/HealthMedco Containment Life Ins Co $6,670,879 0.6%00
2019Individual Accident/HealthBankers Life & Cas Co $6,393,031 0.5%00
2018AutoState Farm Mut Auto Ins Co $133,831,110 12.8%00
2018AutoFarm Bureau Mut Ins Co Of ID $111,964,098 10.7%10.93
2018AutoSafeco Ins Co Of IL $81,136,546 7.8%33.86
2018AutoFarmers Ins Co Of ID $74,753,282 7.2%00
2018AutoAllstate Fire & Cas Ins Co $63,074,478 6.0%00
2018AutoProgressive Northwestern Ins Co $56,533,418 5.4%00
2018AutoProgressive Direct Ins Co $46,153,854 4.4%00
2018AutoGEICO Advantage Ins Co $42,358,099 4.1%00
2018AutoGEICO Choice Ins Co $27,828,153 2.7%00
2018AutoLM Gen Ins Co $20,868,399 2.0%15.01
2018AutoUnited Serv Automobile Assn $19,891,204 1.9%00
2018AutoUSAA Cas Ins Co $18,550,606 1.8%00
2018AutoViking Ins Co Of WI $18,376,115 1.8%00
2018AutoStandard Fire Ins Co $17,968,966 1.7%00
2018AutoAuto Owners Ins Co $17,824,032 1.7%00
2018AutoGeico Gen Ins Co $17,656,811 1.7%15.92
2018AutoUSAA Gen Ind Co $15,713,167 1.5%00
2018AutoAmerican Family Ins Co $15,436,975 1.5%00
2018AutoState Farm Fire & Cas Co $15,434,401 1.5%00
2018AutoAmerican Family Mut Ins Co SI $12,345,381 1.2%00
2018Group Accident/HealthBlue Cross of ID Hlth Serv Inc $750,985,758 43.6%00
2018Group Accident/HealthRegence Blueshield Of ID Inc $315,782,810 18.3%22.18
2018Group Accident/HealthSelectHealth Inc $95,120,658 5.5%00
2018Group Accident/HealthUnitedHealthcare Ins Co $85,208,499 4.9%00
2018Group Accident/HealthDelta Dental Plan of ID Inc $58,535,109 3.4%00
2018Group Accident/HealthPacificsource Hlth Plans $56,848,785 3.3%00
2018Group Accident/HealthAetna Life Ins Co $52,966,854 3.1%00
2018Group Accident/HealthCigna Hlth & Life Ins Co $38,737,839 2.3%00
2018Group Accident/HealthHumana Ins Co $27,211,251 1.6%00
2018Group Accident/HealthMetropolitan Life Ins Co $16,402,411 1.0%00
2018Group Accident/HealthSilverScript Ins Co $14,908,536 0.9%00
2018Group Accident/HealthStandard Ins Co $13,559,071 0.8%00
2018Group Accident/HealthWillamette Dental of ID Inc $11,685,291 0.7%00
2018Group Accident/HealthLife Ins Co Of N Amer $11,575,169 0.7%00
2018Group Accident/HealthUnum Life Ins Co Of Amer $8,457,936 0.5%00
2018Group Accident/HealthPrincipal Life Ins Co $7,816,698 0.5%00
2018Group Accident/HealthMedco Containment Life Ins Co $7,389,478 0.4%00
2018Group Accident/HealthTimber Products Manufacturers Trust $6,977,361 0.4%00
2018Group Accident/HealthHartford Life & Accident Ins Co $5,927,337 0.3%00
2018Group Accident/HealthReliance Standard Life Ins Co $5,815,966 0.3%00
2018HomeownerState Farm Fire & Cas Co $58,272,243 15.1%00
2018HomeownerSafeco Ins Co Of IL $38,557,487 10.0%00
2018HomeownerFarm Bureau Mut Ins Co Of ID $37,996,722 9.8%00
2018HomeownerFarmers Ins Exch $22,152,578 5.7%00
2018HomeownerAllstate Vehicle & Prop Ins Co $14,840,544 3.8%00
2018HomeownerUnited Heritage Prop & Cas Co $12,791,222 3.3%00
2018HomeownerUnited Serv Automobile Assn $12,335,569 3.2%00
2018HomeownerFarmers Ins Co Of ID $12,010,502 3.1%00
2018HomeownerTravelers Home & Marine Ins Co $11,319,697 2.9%00
2018HomeownerLiberty Ins Corp $10,584,241 2.7%00
2018HomeownerAuto Owners Ins Co $9,707,664 2.5%00
2018HomeownerForemost Ins Co Grand Rapids MI $7,835,576 2.0%00
2018HomeownerUSAA Cas Ins Co $7,785,635 2.0%00
2018HomeownerAmerican Family Mut Ins Co SI $7,320,071 1.9%00
2018HomeownerAllstate Prop & Cas Ins Co $6,113,994 1.6%00
2018HomeownerMetropolitan Prop & Cas Ins Co $5,789,718 1.5%00
2018HomeownerMutual Of Enumclaw Ins Co $5,625,037 1.5%168.79
2018HomeownerAllstate Ind Co $5,302,358 1.4%00
2018HomeownerUSAA Gen Ind Co $5,112,435 1.3%00
2018HomeownerEnumclaw Prop & Cas Ins Co $4,941,360 1.3%00
2018Individual Accident/HealthBlue Cross of ID Hlth Serv Inc $383,893,900 33.0%0.337032
2018Individual Accident/HealthSelectHealth Inc $175,185,570 15.1%0.369271
2018Individual Accident/HealthMontana Hlth Cooperative $151,350,698 13.0%3.419388
2018Individual Accident/HealthRegence Blueshield Of ID Inc $69,487,149 6.0%0.930981
2018Individual Accident/HealthDelta Dental Plan of ID Inc $58,535,109 5.0%00
2018Individual Accident/HealthAmerican Family Life Assur Co of Col $32,461,128 2.8%00
2018Individual Accident/HealthHumana Ins Co $27,211,251 2.3%00
2018Individual Accident/HealthContinental Life Ins Co Brentwood $24,304,614 2.1%2.661661
2018Individual Accident/HealthMutual Of Omaha Ins Co $19,075,930 1.6%00
2018Individual Accident/HealthSilverScript Ins Co $14,908,536 1.3%00
2018Individual Accident/HealthWillamette Dental of ID Inc $11,685,291 1.0%00
2018Individual Accident/HealthUnited Of Omaha Life Ins Co $11,530,759 1.0%00
2018Individual Accident/HealthPacificsource Hlth Plans $10,939,280 0.9%00
2018Individual Accident/HealthTransamerica Premier Life Ins Co $9,220,360 0.8%00
2018Individual Accident/HealthAetna Hlth & Life Ins Co $8,032,992 0.7%00
2018Individual Accident/HealthGenworth Life Ins Co $8,007,532 0.7%00
2018Individual Accident/HealthNorthwestern Mut Life Ins Co $7,686,958 0.7%00
2018Individual Accident/HealthMedco Containment Life Ins Co $7,389,478 0.6%00
2018Individual Accident/HealthBankers Life & Cas Co $6,812,031 0.6%00
2018Individual Accident/HealthAmerican Fidelity Assur Co $6,222,734 0.5%00
ver: 3.5.2a | last updated: