Canyon County woman lies to get long-term disability

Wednesday April 28, 2021

BOISE, ID – On Wednesday, April 21, 2021, Evaleen Keim, also known as Evaleen Grimes, pled guilty to insurance fraud in violation of Idaho Code 41-293(1)(c).

Ms. Evaleen Grimes was approved for a substantial long-term disability through October 18, 2017 after encountering injuries from getting bucked off a horse. When Ms. Grimes returned to work on May 30, 2017, she failed to inform the insurance company providing her disability coverage from the accident.

The insurance company asked Ms. Grimes on two separate occasions if she was working, and she stated she was not working both times. Ms. Grimes case was referred to the Investigations Unit at the Department of Insurance (DOI) and consequently admitted to DOI investigators that she lied about going back to work in order to continue getting disability checks to cover financial needs. On February 20, 2021, Ms. Grimes appeared before Judge C. Nye in Canyon County and pled guilty.

"Unfortunately, insurance fraud is never a victimless crime and the outcome is the increase of insurance premiums for hard-working Idahoans,” said Director Dean Cameron. “I appreciate the hard work of our Investigations Division for holding this individual’s actions accountable.”

District Judge C. Nye of Canyon County ordered Ms. Keim to pay courts costs plus restitution in the amount of $413.25 to the DOI for investigative costs. She is also on a payment plan for restitution owed to the insurance company. Judge Nye imposed 180 days of jail time with 170 days suspended. He also withheld judgement and placed Ms. Keim on probation for one year. The remaining 10 days of jail time can be fulfilled by completing 40 hours of community service. The Office of the Attorney General’s Special Prosecutions Unit prosecuted this case.

About the Department of Insurance

The Idaho Department of Insurance has been regulating the business of insurance in Idaho since 1901. The mission of the Department is to serve and protect Idahoans by equitably, effectively and efficiently administering the Idaho Insurance Code and the International Fire Code. For more information, please visit us at


View this release as a PDF